Reading the Past


The Impersonator by Mary Miley, a novel of vaudeville, deception, and mystery in the Roaring ’20s

Although Mary Miley’s heroine may be a con artist, her fresh narrative voice and down-on-her-luck desperation invite you to understand the choices she makes and why. On the vaudeville circuit, Leah Randall’s youthful looks have helped her go far, but her newest gig stands to test her acting skills to the utmost.

When Oliver Beckett spots her on stage in Omaha in 1924, he’s less impressed by her routine than her eerie resemblance to his niece, Jessie Carr, a lumber heiress who disappeared nearly seven years ago, when she was 14. Jessie is set to inherit the Carr fortune when she turns 21, but now she’s nowhere to be found.

Oliver offers Leah the permanent role of Jessie under the condition that she’ll split the dough with him once she gets it. After she’s let go from her longtime role in a family act, she knows it’s a challenge she can’t refuse.

Leah is easy to root for, since she doesn’t have evil intentions. She’s just a young woman who has the talent and needs the money, and her story will make you forget where you are and lose yourself in the show. The part calls for improvisation, special training, and quick, intense study, with her greedy and unscrupulous “Uncle Oliver” feeding her many of the details she’ll need. To succeed, she must convince the trustees of Carr Industries that she’s really Jessie, then insinuate herself within Jessie’s family at the Carr estate of Cliff House, an enormous “summer cottage” along Oregon’s coast. And not everyone there is happy to welcome Jessie back.

The Impersonator, winner of the Minotaur Books/Mystery Writers of America First Crime Novel Award for 2012, offers many mysteries in one, and they coil suspensefully together to form a complicated puzzle. Will Leah’s depiction be convincing enough? Why do dangerous accidents keep following her? What happened to the real Jessie, and will she resurface to put in her own claim?

To assuage her growing sense of guilt at deceiving her newfound relatives, Leah launches her own secret investigation into Jessie’s disappearance and stumbles into more than she bargained for.

Miley takes a world that has vanished into the shadows of nearly a century ago and pulls it back onto center stage. Her re-created atmosphere of Prohibition-era America hums with vibrant life: the decadent glamour of vaudeville, the crafty trade of smuggled hooch, and the racial tensions threatening to boil over in the culturally diverse Pacific Northwest. She also includes just enough period lingo to give a sense of the era without overdoing it. It’s a tightly woven performance, and a totally enjoyable one.

The Impersonator will be published on September 17th by Minotaur Books ($24.99, hb, 358pp). Thanks to the publisher for sending me a review copy.  Visit the author’s website, her blog Mary Miley’s Roaring ’20s, and also her site on History Myths Debunked.  Tune in next Tuesday, also, when she’ll be stopping by with a fun article about vaudeville memorabilia.

Posted by at 9:00 AM 


  1. Great review, Sarah. This book sounds fabulous. Adding it to my Goodreads list right now and looking forward to reading it. Your reviews have never let me down!


  2. Thanks, Jessica – we must have very similar tastes in books! This book was a lot of fun, and I’m thinking I have a new favorite decade to read about. I’m fascinated by vaudeville.

  3. Anonymous10:46 AM

    Terrific review! Can’t wait to read Mary’s book.


  4. Hope you’ll enjoy it also!

  5. Already on my wishlist!! Looking forward to it.


  6. This one had been on my wishlist for a while, ever since a librarian friend told me about it. It’s a good one if you like reading about women of the early 20th century. If you read it, I’d be interested to hear what you think!

  7. Excellent write-up, Sarah, and I agree with every word. And FYI, Minotaur has already agreed to publish the second book in the series, and Mary just finished writing a third.


  8. That’s excellent news that there will be more. Leah/”Jessie” wasn’t your typical amateur detective, so it wasn’t apparent that this was first in a series, but I’m glad it is!

  9. It was great! I seriously hated to put it down.


  10. Glad you agree!


Published in: on October 22, 2013 at 7:10 am  Leave a Comment  

The URI to TrackBack this entry is:

RSS feed for comments on this post.

What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: